Skip to Main Content

Multilevel Modeling FAQs: How do I interpret models with different kinds of centering?

Let’s consider a large number of different possible centering techniques, both
at level 1 and level 2 and see how they impact the interpretation of the
intercept and slopes.  Say that we have an outcome variable called "read"
and a predictor called "iq" and we have the data at 2 levels, at the student
level (level 1) and the school level (level 2),  We have 3 schools with 4
students within each school.

If we ran a separate regression predicting "read"
from "iq" for each school, we would find that this slope would be about 1 within
each school. This represents the within school relationship between "read" and "iq"
and is graphed below.

Image int_cent1

If we average the "iq" and "read" scores across schools (creating 3 scores)
and perform a regression predicting "read" from "iq" we would find that the
regression predicting "read" from "iq" between the groups has a slope of
approximately 10.  This represents the between school relationship between
"iq" and "read".

Image int_cent2

Let’s now consider how we might analyze this data using a multilevel model,
looking at both the level 1 effect of "iq" (at the student level) and the level
2 effect of "iq" (at the school level).  Consider these 3 different ways we
could center the predictor "iq" at level 1.

In addition, we wish to have a "contextual" effect, representing the effect
of the average level of "iq" for the school.  This could be centered in one
of 2 ways.

This yields a 2 by 3 table showing the different results.  B0 represents
the intercept, B1 represents the slope for "iq" at level 1, and B2 represents
the slope for "iq" at level 2.

  Level 1: IQGrpCen Level 1: IQGrdCen Level 1: IQ
Level 2: MeanIQGrdCen B0=12.167
B1=1.02
B2=10
B0=12.167
B1=1.02
B2=8.98
B0 = 9.617
B1 = 1.02
B2=8.98
Level 2: MeanIQ B0 = -12.832
B1 = 1.02
B2 = 9.99
B0 = -10.285
B1 = 1.02
B2 = 8.98
B0= -12.833
B1= 1.02
B2 = 8.98

Notice the following

In summary, the two centering techniques from row 1, columns 1 and 2 yield
what appear to be the most interpretable results.  In both cases at level 2
IQ is grand mean centered, and then averaged across the schools.  Then, if
you group mean center IQ and at level 1 then the intercept is the predicted mean
reading score for a student of average IQ from a school of average IQ.  The
slope for B1 is the average increase in "read" you would expect when a students
"iq" raises by 1 point, and the slope for B2 is the average increase in "read"
you would expect when the schools average IQ increases by 1 point.  If
instead you grand mean center IQ (row 1, column 2), the interpretation of B0 and
B1 is the same, except that B2 is interpreted as the difference in the level 2
slope for "iq" minus the level 1 slope for "iq" (the between school slope for "iq"
minus the within school slope for "iq").